| HarryHotspurEsq | 31 Mar 2012 2:14 p.m. PST |
Hi, for sum time I've felt the niggling urge to see my beloved Seleukids in 6mm. The thought of seeing multiple scythed chariots or elephants maneuvering as a unit against a backdrop of massed pike blocks and having cavalry in different formations. Quite enticing I think. So I guess before I get into it: i) how many people actually play 6mm scale ancients, ii) what is the preferred rules set, iii) how compatible are different manufacturers (principally Baccus and Heroics and Ros) Cheers! |
| SteelonSand | 31 Mar 2012 2:47 p.m. PST |
In answer to iii) – Heroics and Ros are teeny-tiny compared to Baccus, as well as being 'smoother' in terms of detailing – i.e. very low on detail or definition which depending on what you are looking for can either be a positive or a negative. A good mix for Baccus would be the great range from Rapier Miniatures - rapierminiatures.co.uk very similar in terms of heft, height and definition. Honourable mention goes to Irregular Miniatures, although they too are on the slight side when put next to Baccus, and the somewhat 'irregular' sculpting is a bit of an acquired taste
.. Baccus vs Rapier vs Irregular (albeit Romans) can be seen at my Blog: link Hope this helps. |
| elsyrsyn | 31 Mar 2012 3:51 p.m. PST |
So I guess before I get into it: i) how many people actually play 6mm scale ancients, ii) what is the preferred rules set, iii) how compatible are different manufacturers (principally Baccus and Heroics and Ros) i) Not as many as game in 15mm, certainly, but new converts see the light daily. ii) Anything you like, really. I game with 6mm minis on 15mm scale bases, using the usual WRG sizes. iii) SteelonSand covered this beautifully. I'm very partial to Baccus minis myself. Doug |
| GreyONE | 31 Mar 2012 4:43 p.m. PST |
From the miniatures I have in my collections: Heroics & Ros: 5mm scale if you measure from the bottom of their feet to the top of their heads. 6mm scale if you measure from the bottom of their stands to the tops of their heads (not counting helmets).. When compared to Baccus of Rapier, H&R tend to be skinny. Nice figs, but less mass and detail. Baccus vs Rapier: Figures vary a bit, but are around 7.5mm from bottom of feet to the tops of heads (not counting helmets). Baccus and Rapier are compatible when mixed. Both make nice minis. At this time I just play ancient naval in 1/300th scale, but would love to expand this to land combat as well.
|
| HarryHotspurEsq | 31 Mar 2012 5:59 p.m. PST |
Rapier do look nice, but if I venture down the 6mm path, I'll want camelry and Arab archers to support my Seleukids
. |
| Skipper | 31 Mar 2012 7:18 p.m. PST |
I love 6mm miniatures for ancients, they just look great in the battle formation. I use mainly Baccus, but have a few H&R also. They don't mix well, but in separatee units its not too bad. We play FOG and Hail Caeser in 6mm for ancients. I highly recomend Hail Caeser for a fun game, without getting too bogged down, |
| yorkie o1 | 31 Mar 2012 10:58 p.m. PST |
As has been said, Baccus do a large range, very nice figs they are too, ive also seen Rapier minis and they are similar. Rules wise, Hail Caesar works well, as does Impetus. I based all my 6mm stuff on Impetus bases and use them for both rule-sets. Baccus in re-sculpting their ancients ranges and the new models look great. Steve |
| Angel Barracks | 31 Mar 2012 10:58 p.m. PST |
Irregular Miniatures get a bad press. But with their figures being moulded shoulder to shoulder they look great for blocks of men. Their ancients rules are nice and simple but effective too. Not to mention they have a great selection to pick from: link
link link Michael.
|
| HarryHotspurEsq | 01 Apr 2012 1:04 a.m. PST |
Anyone playing Warmaster Ancients with 6mm figures? Any suggestions of Arab archers and (more importantly) camels to supplement Baccus Hellenistic stuff? @yorkie – do you know anything about Baccus re-sculpting the Hellenistic line? Will it happen and is there any advertised ETA? @Angel barracks – Irregular might be ok in 6mm, but I have been disappointed with their stuff a few too many times in 15mm which makes me a bit hesitant. |
| Angel Barracks | 01 Apr 2012 1:10 a.m. PST |
Why not just get a few strips from them, you could get a rough idea for $10.00 AUD Totally understand what you mean though! |
| Mollinary | 01 Apr 2012 1:35 a.m. PST |
Harry, There was a thread back in 2010 on a similar topic, entitled "6mm Romans" , in which comparison between Baccus and Rapier figured heavily. I have both, and stand by my comments from 2010. But Baccus have a much more comprehensive range, and their new sculpts are outstanding. They are also starting on the re-vamp of their Macedonian (and I assume, Successor?) range. I would also strongly recommend you look at doing 6mm using the Commands and Colors Ancients games, and substituting figures for the blocks. This has also been discussed many times on this forum. Mollinary |
| Caesar | 01 Apr 2012 4:13 a.m. PST |
I used to play Warmaster Ancients with 6mm. They work well. I am switching over to Hail Caesar, it is a further evolution of the Warmaster design. |
| Martin Rapier | 02 Apr 2012 5:15 a.m. PST |
Our 6mm stuff is mostly Baccus. Based for DBA (15mm bases) but used to play Lost Battles & CnC Ancients mostly these days. |
| Jay Arnold | 02 Apr 2012 8:56 a.m. PST |
I agree with Mollinary and Martin Rapier. My figures are based for DBx but I play Commands & Colors: Ancients (CCA). The discussion on the figures is above. So, I'll throw in on the rules. CCA is a great game. The card-based activation injects a level of friction in a way that other games simply don't. Unlike Warmaster/Hail Caesar, there's always something you can do. Having a hand of cards allows one to look to the next two or three rounds and set up a flank for a massive assault. The regular game plays in under an hour usually, even when teaching players new to the game. If playing with miniatures, there are hexless rules available, as are the basic rules, for free at ccancients.net. Command card decks are available for sale, supposedly, but I haven't found them. I'm not overly happy with the stock dice provided. Luckily, Valley Games makes lovely wooden dice for the game. They're relatively cheap, too: link If you want to use a hex mat, Hotz Mats makes a CCA mat with section lines. Alternately, one can easily make one. Good luck! |
| DBS303 | 03 Apr 2012 4:55 a.m. PST |
The only caveat I would offer on the comments above is that whilst Baccus and Rapier infantry mix well, cavalry can be a bit more iffy – the Rapier horses to my mind are just too small. Sadly, even more so the Rapier Arabs on camels – they look more like two chaps mounted in tandem on a small pony IMO – which is a real shame since the only camels produced by Baccus are ancient Cataphract camels and some in the Mahdist range. Now the latter are perfectly passable for, say, Islamic Conquest period armies, but the turban, etc, is probably too late looking for Seleucids. That said, Pete Berry has (rashly) promised in the past that when he resculpts the Baccus Successor range (the revamped Macedonian range is hopefully coming out just in time for Salute in a couple of weeks time), that he will include Arabs on camels. But I presume that the timeframe is later this year, rather than imminently. |
| Elenderil | 04 Apr 2012 12:47 p.m. PST |
I have both irregular and Bacchus figures in 6mm. Bacchus are better individual sculpts but are not true 6mm. That said they are really nice figures and look great en masse. irregular have a wider range and also look great en masse. However they are cast as blocks of figures in many cases and the blocks don't always close up to each other as well as I might like. If I was starting out from scratch I would probably go with Bacchus where they have figures to suit. As for rules I am not in a position to comment as I am returning to ancients after a period away doing ECW so I am just trying rules out my self. That said I like big tables with lots of figures so DBA doesn't work that well for me. Currently I am looking at DBM as I have a copy lying around. I looked at basic impetuous but like DBA it doesn't have the big battle feel for me. |
miniMo  | 04 Apr 2012 6:19 p.m. PST |
DBA or Big Battle DBA works very nicely for me. |
| smacdowall | 05 Apr 2012 1:55 a.m. PST |
I have pics of all manufacturers on my website and the pluses and minus of each are well argued above. For my part my favourite pike figures are Heroics and Ross. See for example the pic at link of Magnesia and the Romans at link The thing about H&R is that they look really fantastic en-masse even if individually they are not as good as Baccus or Rapier. Although the sizes of figures are different I actually find no trouble in mixing all manufacturers (although not in the same units). If you put the H&R figures on thicker bases they can stand alongside the larger figures. I have a painting guide for 6mil at link where you can also see my H&R phalangites. I have also specifically designed rules for 6mil Ancients and they can be downloaded for free at link |