"Mortars: Effective Range?" Topic
10 Posts
All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.
Please be courteous toward your fellow TMP members.
For more information, see the TMP FAQ.
Back to the Modern Discussion (1946 to 2013) Message Board
Areas of InterestModern
Featured Hobby News Article
Featured Recent Link
Top-Rated Ruleset
Featured Showcase Article
Featured Workbench ArticleOne way to base Modern Pulp figures for a wide variety of environments.
Current Poll
Featured Book Review
Featured Movie Review
|
MajerBlundor | 20 Aug 2008 4:49 p.m. PST |
I've seen a few different "effective ranges" for modern mortars quoted. Maybe some are based on earlier, cold war models or maybe the shorter ones are more "reality based". Opinion on below? (we're talking US versions here and HE rounds
insights into foreign models welcome!) 60mm mortar: 3500m (sources pretty consistent) 81mm mortar: 4500m, 5700m, or 6,000m 4.2" mortarL 4800m, 5500m, or 6500m 120mm mortar: 7,200m (sources consistent) The sources for the 4.2" mortar are pretty clear that we're talking about different models and shells with the most recent versions of the 4.2" firing a particular HE round about 6500m. But the 81mm sources are all over the place. For example, "modern" sources such as a book on the initial invasion of Iraq quotes the range for the 81mm at 4500m but other sources show 6,000m. So, both are clearly talking about modern 81mm mortars currently in service. |
Blind Old Hag | 20 Aug 2008 7:54 p.m. PST |
From what I remember, range was dependent upon the ammunition rather that the specific type of mortar. When we switched over from the M29 to the M252 mortar, a new type of ammunition was introduced as well. But, IIRC we did at times use the older ammo intended for the M29 in the M252. With that said, I seem to recall that the older ammo for the m29 had a max range of about 4500 meters, while the newer ammo had a max range of about 5700 meters give or take. |
Blind Old Hag | 20 Aug 2008 8:03 p.m. PST |
Although we never used the newer ammo in the m29, you could do so. But you were limited to using less than a full charge (up to charge three or four IIRC instead of a full charge of nine) which would reduce the max range. |
nevals | 20 Aug 2008 8:04 p.m. PST |
As I remember ,Yugoslav M68,81mm,was said to be effective for up to 6000m.That was likely more in theory than in real life.As Hag said ,it depends upon the ammunition.I used to shoot a lot from it;at 2500m you could hit a fly.Not me ,though.I am not able to shoot apuck in the ocean. |
Blind Old Hag | 20 Aug 2008 8:19 p.m. PST |
Im mistaken in my last post. The newer ammo had up to four charges not nine, and was limited to three when used in the m29. |
rdjktjrfdj | 21 Aug 2008 1:56 a.m. PST |
Looking at the Yugoslav Defence Production Catalogue The 60mm M57 mortar has a minimum range of 74m and maximum 2537m with the M73 shell. It can use HE shells M57, M69 and M73, A smoke shell, an illuminating shell and a practice shell. The 60,, M70 commando type Maximum range 1630m It uses the same shells as the previous. 81/82mm M31 Minimum range approximately 85m Maximum 3145m or 3600 with M74 shell. Ammunition He of 3,1 and 3,4kg Smoke Illuminating practice and practice with 2 target parachutists 81/82mm M69 It can have a long or a short barrel. Maximum range for HE 4,1kg shell 5400m for 3,1kg HE shell 4900m Minimum range 90m Ammunition HE 3,1kg HE 4,1kg smoke 3,1kg Smoke 4,2kg Illuminating Practice practice with 2 parachutists 120mm UB M52 Maximum range for light HE and smoke 6050m For heavy HE 4840m Minimum for both heavy and light HE 400m Ammunition HE M62, 12,6kg HE heavy M49P1, 16kg Smoke M64, 12kg Illuminating 120mm M74 minimum range with light shell 300m maximum with the same shell 6400m Uses the same shells as the previous This doesn't mean much to me, but the remainder is completely beyond me. There are many other data, velocity, increments, weight of parts, barrel lengths, rate of fire, horizontal and vertical field of action, crew, transport, efficiency, sighting devices and some diagrams of range.
Also, unlike for other artillery pieces, the catalogue nowhere states the efficient range of mortars. If you'd like I can photograph the pages (no scanner) and send them to you. They are in English. |
rdjktjrfdj | 21 Aug 2008 1:58 a.m. PST |
for the M69 the ranges are only given for the short barreled version. |
MajerBlundor | 21 Aug 2008 5:31 a.m. PST |
Great information Nikola! No need to send, what you've provided is more than sufficient. Thanks so much, I truly appreciate your efforts and level of detail! |
rdjktjrfdj | 21 Aug 2008 6:33 a.m. PST |
You are welcome. It really was not difficult. |
Blind Old Hag | 21 Aug 2008 9:25 a.m. PST |
In theory, the max range of a specific ammunition type is its' effective range. However, there are factors that can reduce (or increase) the max range such as weather, terrain, and the ammunition itself. We always tried to emplace our mortars in a position where we could engage most targets at up to 3/4 of max range. We could still engage targets farther out, but as the range to the target approached the max range of the ammunition, there was no guarantee that you could hit the target. |
|